Would You Be a Good Mentor?
mercoledì, aprile 13th, 2011by Valerie Ryder and Lee Kirkpatrick Smith
Following its successful first edition, the PWA Milan Mentoring Program is going into round two and opening the application process to mentors in mid-April 2011. Curious about becoming a mentor and what it means? Perhaps you are wondering if you have what it takes. Most likely, you do!
If you are reading this, you probably already have the three characteristics of a good mentor: relevant experience or knowledge, communication skills and willingness to contribute to the success of others.
Don’t be afraid of being a mentor: you will be surprised at how much you are able to offer your mentee by listening and talking. While a commitment, mentoring takes only 1-2 hours per month and can be done at your office, over lunch or even during an aperitivo after work.
Mentoring is not only an act of generosity: being a mentor is rewarding and beneficial for the mentor as well as the mentee. Proof of this is that more than ¾ of the mentors from last year’s program who responded to a follow-up survey are willing to serve as mentors again!
A common theme among mentors is the satisfaction they gain from the experience. There is much gratification to be had from helping someone make good career decisions: “It gave me great pleasure and fulfillment to see someone blooming and developing as my mentee did.” Many women also enjoy giving back to a system from which they themselves have benefitted, while others want their mentee to “benefit from my mistakes”.
And while personal satisfaction and developing relationships are a great motivator for many, some mentors take an even broader point-of-view: “we are contributing to making the world a better (work)place for our daughters”. Recent research has shown that advancing women at all levels contributes to making businesses more profitable.
Finally, mentoring offers tangible benefits to the mentor’s career as well:*
- Mentors gain respect and recognition from others as individuals who are able to identify, encourage and promote talent
- Mentoring a future leader can extend the mentor’s network by providing access not only to the current connections of the mentee, but also to the connections the mentee will develop in the future
- In cross-generational pairs, mentees provide mentors with insights to another generation
An effective mentor in a network mentoring program such as PWA’s is somewhat different from a traditional corporate mentor. To clarify this distinction, we have identified the ideal characteristics of mentors in the PWA program, as well as the roles they may fulfill.
Characteristics of PWA Milan Mentors
1. Relevant experience and/or knowledge. Potential mentors need to have knowledge — general, technical, or skill-related — or experience in a certain area which could be useful to an aspiring mentee. The first part is easy – we all have experience and knowledge. The second part – is it useful to someone else — is where there may be uncertainty. The answer is: it is very likely that it would be beneficial. To be sure, apply as a mentor – you never know who may be in need of the experience you’ve got!
2. Communication skills. Effective mentors are skilled in a certain number of key communication areas, such as active listening, providing constructive feedback, and demonstrating empathy. The training workshop we will be holding for all participants will cover a number of these competencies.
3. Willingness and availability to contribute to the success of others. PWA mentors need to want to help fellow women in their professional advancement, and commit to the availability requirements of the program, knowing that they in turn will surely derive worthwhile benefits in the process.
Reminder: There is no minimum age, seniority, professional level, or educational qualifications in the PWA Mentoring Program.
Various Roles of Mentors
In the PWA program, we anticipate that mentors will play one or two of the roles described here*, but certainly not all of them. In fact, it is widely recommended that women develop a panel of mentors – both women and men – with diverse backgrounds, skills and connections, in order to receive the different types of guidance and support they may need.
Counselor. In this role, fundamental in a network mentoring program such as PWA’s, the mentor is supportive and acts as a sounding board to help her mentee successfully move forward professionally.
- Offers suggestions based on her own professional experience and helps mentee avoid any mistakes she may have made.
- Candidly shares issues related to gender in the workplace.
- Helps the mentee strategize to achieve career goals and weigh the pros and cons of career choices.
- Explains the unwritten rules in the mentee’s environment.
- Assists with strategies for time management essential to balancing work and personal life.
Coach/Advisor. The mentor may serve as a coach/advisor in giving candid feedback, providing assistance with career development, and advising on how to accomplish objectives. Although coaching and mentoring are overall quite different, this is one area where there is some overlap.
- Helps the mentee clarify her performance objectives and areas she would like to develop.
- Offers the mentee candid feedback and provides specific recommendations on areas in which the mentee would like to improve.
Role Model. In certain cases, the mentor may be an inspiring role model. Observing how others conduct themselves and interact with others is often cited by successful individuals as one of their key strategies.
- Leads by example.
- Demonstrates knowledge and insight into applicable informal political processes.
- Exhibits components of an effective leadership style.
Advocate. The mentor may, from time to time, act as a sponsor for the mentee.
- Opens doors and introduces the mentee to select members of the mentor’s network of contacts.
- Informs her mentee about any appropriate professional or educational opportunities she may be aware of.
Note to mentees: Please do not expect this of your mentors – this is a potential added benefit!
As you can see, Mentoring is a terrific way to benefit another woman’s professional development and gain personal and professional rewards for yourself. Giving truly is better than receiving, and we hope you will join our ranks!
For more information on the PWA Milan Mentoring Program, contact us at professional@pwa-milan.org.
• Valerie Ryder, 2010-11 Mentoring Program Leader and Professional Development Director
• Lee Kirkpatrick Smith, 2011 Mentoring Program Coordinator
* Adapted from “Creating Successful Mentoring Programs: A Catalyst Guide”.



































